Retina MacBook Pro - OS X 10.7 vs. OS X 10.8 Performance

Benchmarks of performance comparing Apple OS X 10.7 Lion vs. OS X 10.8 Mountain Lion on the mid-2012 Apple MacBook Pro with Retina Display and Intel Core i7 2.3GHz Ivy Bridge processor with switchable Intel HD 4000 / NVIDIA Kepler graphics. Benchmarking by Michael Larabel of Phoronix.com for a future article. Unfortunately Ubuntu Linux is currently borked on the Retina MacBook Pro.

Compare your own system(s) to this result file with the Phoronix Test Suite by running the command: phoronix-test-suite benchmark 1307022-UT-1208098SU38
Jump To Table - Results

View

Do Not Show Noisy Results
Do Not Show Results With Incomplete Data
Do Not Show Results With Little Change/Spread
List Notable Results

Limit displaying results to tests within:

Timed Code Compilation 2 Tests
C/C++ Compiler Tests 8 Tests
CPU Massive 7 Tests
Creator Workloads 2 Tests
Desktop Graphics 2 Tests
Common Kernel Benchmarks 3 Tests
Multi-Core 5 Tests
Programmer / Developer System Benchmarks 2 Tests
Raytracing 2 Tests
Renderers 2 Tests
Server 2 Tests
Server CPU Tests 5 Tests
Single-Threaded 2 Tests

Statistics

Show Overall Harmonic Mean(s)
Show Overall Geometric Mean
Show Geometric Means Per-Suite/Category
Show Wins / Losses Counts (Pie Chart)
Normalize Results
Remove Outliers Before Calculating Averages

Graph Settings

Force Line Graphs Where Applicable
Convert To Scalar Where Applicable
Prefer Vertical Bar Graphs

Additional Graphs

Show Perf Per Core/Thread Calculation Graphs Where Applicable
Show Perf Per Clock Calculation Graphs Where Applicable

Multi-Way Comparison

Condense Multi-Option Tests Into Single Result Graphs

Table

Show Detailed System Result Table

Run Management

Highlight
Result
Hide
Result
Result
Identifier
View Logs
Performance Per
Dollar
Date
Run
  Test
  Duration
OS X 10.7.4
July 30 2012
 
OS X 10.8.0
July 30 2012
 
test
March 13 2013
 
10.8.4
May 10 2013
 
KINGSTON SVP100S296G
May 18 2013
 
12e52
May 20 2013
 
12e55
May 25 2013
 
bench1mav
June 29 2013
 
OS X 10.7.4 11G63
July 02 2013
 
Invert Hiding All Results Option
 

Only show results where is faster than
Only show results matching title/arguments (delimit multiple options with a comma):
Do not show results matching title/arguments (delimit multiple options with a comma):


Retina MacBook Pro - OS X 10.7 vs. OS X 10.8 Performance, "X-Plane 9.45 - Quality Setting: High - Resolution: 2880 x 1800", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",62,62 "OS X 10.8.0",63,63,63 "test",8,8,8 "10.8.4",9,8,9,9,9,9 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",9,9,9 "12e52",9,9,9 "12e55",8,8,8 "bench1mav",9,9,9 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",9,8,7,7,6,6 "X-Plane 9.45 - Quality Setting: High - Resolution: 2560 x 1600", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",70,70 "OS X 10.8.0",74,73,73 "test",9,9,9 "10.8.4",10,10,10 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",10,10,10 "12e52",10,10,10 "12e55",9,10,10,10,10,10 "bench1mav",10,10,10 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",10,10,10 "Tachyon 0.98.9 - Total Time", Lower Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",14.8706,14.8848,14.7579 "OS X 10.8.0",14.8494,14.7795,14.7357 "test",78.4912,77.8438,78.7227 "10.8.4",116.1235,119.0151,118.7048 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",76.3929,75.4336,76.6218 "12e52",75.9688,75.9635,75.9734 "12e55",98.2633,90.6109,89.7519,90.5134,90.5998,90.7361 "bench1mav",76.7744,76.2671,76.9234 "X-Plane 9.45 - Quality Setting: High - Resolution: 1920 x 1080", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",106,105,103 "OS X 10.8.0",106,105,108 "test",14,14,14 "10.8.4",15,15,15 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",15,15,15 "12e52",15,15,15 "12e55",15,15,15 "bench1mav",14,14,14 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",16,16,16 "Timed ImageMagick Compilation 6.6.3-4 - Time To Compile", Lower Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",37.109871149063,38.969503164291,38.926692962646 "OS X 10.8.0",33.175994157791,33.11180305481,33.255627155304 "test",223.23894095421,224.74581408501,217.95684599876 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",181.32050180435,181.94196295738,181.70932388306 "Timed PHP Compilation 5.2.9 - Time To Compile", Lower Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",29.884467840195,30.062469005585,30.266096115112 "OS X 10.8.0",31.581937074661,31.660722970963,31.616992950439 "test",156.14699792862,156.19680190086,156.95416498184 "10.8.4",169.38322806358,169.62044692039,169.56687617302 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",151.43753409386,151.50970387459,151.39512300491 "12e52",165.02284002304,165.34587621689,165.14675617218 "12e55",196.18798017502,198.02828216553,195.69373822212 "bench1mav",121.91944408417,135.47013688087,135.69861006737,135.83970689774,138.35361099243,136.32582879066 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",136.29690814018,133.09506917,123.73262000084,130.79765605927,131.29360103607,129.88793206215 "OpenArena 0.8.5 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",218.2,219.7,220.5 "OS X 10.8.0",254.6,248.3,253.7 "test",40.4,40.6,40.5 "10.8.4",57.6,57.8,57.7 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",63,62.7,63.1 "12e52",60.2,60.4,60.2 "12e55",55.1,55.2,55.3 "bench1mav",58.7,58.9,58.9 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",61.8,61.3,61.3 "Stream 2009-04-11 - Type: Triad", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",16249.1196,16238.6346,16238.6346,16271.4452,16254.3672,16173.4087,16205.956,16205.956,16276.7073,16243.8754 "OS X 10.8.0",16048.3533,15841.2615,16053.472,15903.8306,16053.472,16033.0168,15926.4767,16090.6803,16080.3987,16021.5337 "test",3118.2967,3000.933,2792.4794,3068.0675,2717.6916,2983.0581,2864.3096,2920.7821,2863.7799,2792.9442,2618.0992,2814.9298,2932.2253,3110.6361,2745.0382,2566.0102,2732.5569,2781.9452,3068.0675,3078.7178 "10.8.4",3404.007,3386.486,3389.7931,3381.4806,3394.3653,3400.6147,3343.0738,3378.87,3376.49,3358.0737 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",3403.0289,3405.4465,3432.0348,3394.1364,3382.4464,3392.0205,3383.1285,3383.6402,3383.1285,3367.4538 "12e52",3277.12,3321.7825,3310.0949,3333.7737,3289.274,3302.3849,3325.4586,3311.8918,3338.4173,3323.647 "12e55",3266.8569,3218.8564,3254.4469,3247.2031,3166.6078,3184.9426,3227.3186,3211.5651,3183.2304 "bench1mav",3715.4039,3667.2178,3696.847,3662.9477,3664.6812,3663.0143,3656.0298,3663.2809,3664.6812,3659.4189 "Stream 2009-04-11 - Type: Add", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",15963.098,15946.6608,15883.7548,15921.4387,15968.1624,15903.8306,15963.098,15915.1456,15921.4387,15936.5623 "OS X 10.8.0",15640.6613,15589.7934,15675.9785,15599.457,15753.2545,15717.5886,15564.4833,15779.1827,15707.7781,15758.1866 "test",2912.0791,3137.4432,3048.7861,2850.1981,2883.2611,2784.0611,2885.989,2929.7078,2731.4817,2639.5179,2951.0941,2477.1645,3036.2796,2914.018,2866.1854,2891.045,2809.9794,2857.8448,2903.4697,2811.4705 "10.8.4",3270.8907,3353.3194,3342.1304,3389.3936,3323.3727,3375.5276,3336.315,3373.8871,3346.7973,3339.5802 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",3353.1519,3359.4746,3357.3457,3342.1859,3356.3942,3373.3783,3344.0178,3345.1846,3330.5749,3343.2959 "12e52",3259.294,3299.192,3255.7626,3250.0862,3271.7412,3284.0694,3273.9758,3282.7307,3283.3732,3278.0271 "12e55",3196.8273,3218.2389,3111.79,3197.4365,3234.7337,3240.6173,3161.635,3241.5043,3211.1553 "bench1mav",3687.1652,3608.5208,3645.4378,3629.7952,3614.4161,3630.8426,3610.9155,3629.9916,3632.2182,3625.0894 "Stream 2009-04-11 - Type: Copy", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",14665.3986,14961.2895,14644.5966,14739.4825,14835.6061,14705.569,14713.6295,14679.8346,14705.569,14631.8247 "OS X 10.8.0",14579.3752,14234.5666,14368.668,13658.0572,14330.3148,13822.629,14134.1331,13468.914,14330.3148,14533.5926 "test",2758.163,2697.1932,2718.9946,2772.979,2908.0411,2360.9099,2895.6814,2796.7271,2771.5474,2882.6212,2525.8333,2813.435,2603.7427,2705.4571,2803.3278,2402.9241,2866.6139,2572.1078,2363.3626,2557.3562 "10.8.4",3088.518,3102.5827,3098.357,3128.0351,3074.5803,3058.1177,3100.5042,3082.5596,3088.8023,3095.9985 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",3103.8024,3077.259,3107.1076,3096.8557,3084.0471,3088.8023,3099.5734,3089.0867,3105.5979,3097.7849 "12e52",3069.5878,3054.0817,3031.1825,3046.1107,3007.815,3057.7694,3041.2102,3066.0117,3054.6377,3029.1302 "12e55",2959.4013,3004.7175,2971.4567,2982.5499,2939.8254,2914.6086,3006.4001,2961.5562,2923.1782 "bench1mav",5131.6279,5138.1107,5150.3349,5143.8213,5157.856,5153.8948,5145.5961,5150.3349,5164.604,5141.2598 "Stream 2009-04-11 - Type: Scale", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",14362.5177,14401.0438,14380.9845,14356.3727,14382.5255,14376.3633,14324.1972,14370.2064,14362.5177,14284.5602 "OS X 10.8.0",14035.107,14292.1657,14065.9954,14122.2357,13985.3838,14165.4594,14114.81,14091.1001,13992.6739,14183.4226 "test",2686.8264,2766.9765,2630.9463,2904.5798,2930.966,2592.1768,2585.2366,2743.9532,2707.7495,2750.5324,2680.7623,2512.5466,2852.0554,2711.6336,2900.6879,2361.9901,2710.7026,2610.7319,2874.0413,2712.0719 "10.8.4",3000.7541,3045.9033,3067.4832,3069.7985,3043.0029,3025.443,3018.0277,3058.1177,3033.4432,3050.1949 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",3060.2095,3056.6552,3068.9561,3067.2028,3050.8189,3043.6239,3060.4188,3069.2369,3052.2759,3058.1177 "12e52",3006.0635,3010.3786,3016.3321,2971.2594,2966.8589,2978.9091,3016.5354,3018.0277,2977.3232,3009.5011 "12e55",2909.8694,2913.0272,2926.684,2882.0642,2887.3342,2888.6391,2943.6294,2958.2924,2941.6939 "bench1mav",3253.9998,3253.6842,3260.0065,3272.3261,3259.6106,3262.3044,3254.9467,3258.9775,3261.5909,3260.0065 "C-Ray 1.1 - Total Time", Lower Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",49.998,50.364,49.967 "OS X 10.8.0",49.979,49.938,49.926 "test",233.518,233.469,252.919,268.378,267.699,253.406 "10.8.4",230.23,227.527,226.256 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",227.032,227.815,225.93 "12e52",230.635,230.098,230.81 "12e55",254.298,253.458,259.621 "bench1mav",165.692,164.208,163.95 "SciMark 2.0 - Computational Test: Dense LU Matrix Factorization", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",2426.46,2396.91,2437.3,2444.5 "OS X 10.8.0",2392.87,2411.65,2393.29,2416.97 "test",475.78,482.98,484.26,497.15 "10.8.4",476.52,475.56,470.76,474.31 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",526.05,531.22,532.7,528.36 "12e52",521.98,525.98,517.55,517.92 "12e55",524.21,503.06,491.87,513.87 "bench1mav",525.55,530.77,526.32,529.79 "SciMark 2.0 - Computational Test: Sparse Matrix Multiply", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",1842.6,1835.83,1856.15,1857.69 "OS X 10.8.0",1816.87,1814.23,1819.3,1831.13 "test",426.17,418.25,420.59,417.81 "10.8.4",392.27,391.9,389.72,392.27 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",485.35,488.95,482.58,483.7 "12e52",485.66,484.2,477.57,482.21 "12e55",443.82,455.5,450.93,456.99 "bench1mav",610.2,606.4,608.43,609.24 "SciMark 2.0 - Computational Test: Fast Fourier Transform", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",296.14,292.85,297.56,294.77 "OS X 10.8.0",279.26,290.45,288.65,281.4 "test",66.67,66.91,66.38,64.23 "10.8.4",65.1,65.9,64.47,65.39 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",69.16,70.87,71.8,72.3 "12e52",68.78,69.72,66.12,69.28 "12e55",69.97,67.14,68.13,65.11 "bench1mav",71.54,73.83,72.4 "PostgreSQL pgbench 8.4.11 - TPC-B Transactions Per Second", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",4213.198518,4355.887003,4235.516158 "OS X 10.8.0",3945.607304,4371.511602,3954.64588,4389.32573,3957.551696,4456.546609 "test",1427.101752,1429.664986,1431.943177 "10.8.4",990.733194,995.564924,988.652706 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",1474.942642,1534.914273,1514.678025 "12e52",1498.198566,1504.837337,1504.121443 "12e55",1259.895746,1300.056875,1294.33837 "bench1mav",1415.033333,1465.365787,1479.802107 "SciMark 2.0 - Computational Test: Composite", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",1280.52,1273.12,1288.28,1289.7 "OS X 10.8.0",1270.21,1275.67,1269.69,1277.02 "test",370.41,370.24,370.87,372.3 "10.8.4",364.84,364.76,363.07,364.65 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",393.54,394.24,394.39,396.04 "12e52",392.15,393.38,390.59,390.82 "12e55",385.06,382.69,379.86,384.71 "bench1mav",425.43,402.15,425.49,402.83 "OpenArena 0.8.5 - Resolution: 2560 x 1600", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",141.6,137.3,143.8 "OS X 10.8.0",255.7,255.2,252.1 "test",88.8,88.5,86 "10.8.4",110.1,110,110.5 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",129.6,130.3,130.2 "12e52",128.3,128.5,128.5 "12e55",109.3,108.3,109.1 "bench1mav",122,121.8,121.7 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",126.2,126.4,126.3 "OpenArena 0.8.5 - Resolution: 2880 x 1800", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",130.5,133,132.3 "OS X 10.8.0",249.7,252.8,246.9 "test",87.2,88.8,89.1 "10.8.4",109.2,109.1,109 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",130.5,130.2,130.2 "12e52",128.7,128.6,128.7 "12e55",108.5,108.4,105.2 "bench1mav",120.8,121,120.7 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",126.2,126.5,126.2 "SciMark 2.0 - Computational Test: Monte Carlo", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",435.02,435.28,437.51,437.52 "OS X 10.8.0",434.32,434.49,436.21,436.27 "test",233.17,233.37,232.79,233.31 "10.8.4",235.35,235.19,235.47,235.78 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",232.86,231.84,231.83,235.98 "12e52",232.39,233.42,233.25,232.6 "12e55",233.56,233.99,233.96 "bench1mav",238.87,120.63,238.67,120.62 "Urban Terror 4.1 - Resolution: 2880 x 1800", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",50,50.8,50.8 "OS X 10.8.0",97.6,98.7,97.2 "test",44.3,43.9,44 "10.8.4",50.8,51,50.6 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",58.1,58.4,58 "12e52",57.7,57.8,57.6 "12e55",49.7,50,50.2 "OpenSSL 1.0.0e - RSA 4096-bit Performance", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",27.7,27.8,27.7,27.6 "OS X 10.8.0",27.8,27.3,27.3,27.2 "test",12.6,12.6,12.6,12.6 "10.8.4",12.6,12.6,12.6,12.6 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",12.6,12.6,12.6,12.6 "12e52",12.6,12.6,12.6,12.6 "12e55",12.6,12.6,12.6,12.6 "bench1mav",12.7,12.7,12.7,12.7 "SciMark 2.0 - Computational Test: Jacobi Successive Over-Relaxation", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",1402.4,1404.73,1412.9,1414.04 "OS X 10.8.0",1408.41,1409.63,1407.13,1408.55 "test",650.26,649.69,650.34 "10.8.4",654.94,655.27,654.94,655.51 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",654.27,648.33,653.02,659.88 "12e52",651.95,653.6,658.44,652.12 "12e55",653.75,653.75,654.41,653.58 "bench1mav",680.98,679.13,681.05,682.12 "Fhourstones 3.1 - Complex Connect-4 Solving", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",10036.8,10053.7,10060.6 "OS X 10.8.0",9973.2,9758.2,9782.4 "test",4854.1,5012.1,5006.1 "10.8.4",5163.3,5087.4,5084.3 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",5200.5,5205.1,5214.5 "12e52",5191,5195.4,5194.5 "12e55",5116,5119.2,5105.3 "bench1mav",5348.9,5346.3,5347.4 "Nexuiz 2.5.2 - Resolution: 2560 x 1600 - HDR: Yes - Sound: On", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",26.3112682,26.8296117,27.2049081 "OS X 10.8.0",26.6229034,27.309439,27.0612702 "test",16.0372679,16.2247728,16.3151971 "10.8.4",15.323337,15.645239,15.6914305 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",21.9237422,21.843506,21.7743342 "12e52",21.5276686,21.5021722,21.3995376 "12e55",19.0272171,19.1019694,19.1027494 "bench1mav",19.7315166,20.077042,20.0007119 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",16.179887,15.4638853,15.3651185 "Nexuiz 2.5.2 - Resolution: 2880 x 1800 - HDR: Yes - Sound: On", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",26.6061491,26.686797,25.8405757 "OS X 10.8.0",26.8139987,26.5106681,27.215595 "test",16.1004444,16.3019095,16.2716893 "10.8.4",15.5218302,15.5774932,15.9709694 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",21.6654035,21.8260181,21.8469931 "12e52",21.5524391,21.108514,21.5083628 "12e55",18.8083837,19.1004736,19.147371 "bench1mav",20.0670576,20.0572811,20.0329362 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",15.1724668,15.3892188,16.2711939,19.843872,19.920089,19.9192842 "Himeno Benchmark 3.0 - Poisson Pressure Solver", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",263.257817,263.022259,263.039733 "OS X 10.8.0",285.125833,284.982051,288.11733 "test",175.513631,173.988471,174.487168 "10.8.4",181.714039,181.808477,180.81639 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",184.13951,182.727335,184.340623 "12e52",183.284831,183.078576,183.274391 "12e55",173.119377,171.856254,172.898592 "bench1mav",265.815909,265.153058,264.862768 "Xonotic 0.6 - Resolution: 2560 x 1600 - Effects Quality: High", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",60.0881886,60.3357315,60.0382116 "OS X 10.8.0",52.7889977,52.6200449,52.7170447 "Xonotic 0.6 - Resolution: 2880 x 1800 - Effects Quality: High", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",54.8208652,55.0489294,55.0107338 "OS X 10.8.0",52.2981747,52.7315753,52.3952579 "Xonotic 0.6 - Resolution: 2560 x 1600 - Effects Quality: Low", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",141.0851728,141.711258,139.9284761 "OS X 10.8.0",135.6230076,135.8329594,135.738478 "Xonotic 0.6 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080 - Effects Quality: Low", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",144.4855918,142.7023779,144.8729123 "OS X 10.8.0",137.6893294,139.5817991,139.5678527 "Xonotic 0.6 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080 - Effects Quality: High", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",71.8756356,72.178194,72.4705256 "OS X 10.8.0",70.9536258,71.7126503,71.5966309 "Warsow 1.0 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",48.5,48.5,46.5 "OS X 10.8.0",47.9,48,49 "Warsow 1.0 - Resolution: 2880 x 1800", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",45.4,48.9,47.7,49.8,48.3 "OS X 10.8.0",48.4,47.7,49.1 "Warsow 1.0 - Resolution: 2560 x 1600", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",47.8,48.2,47.5 "OS X 10.8.0",45.8,48.1,48.7 "Xonotic 0.6 - Resolution: 2880 x 1800 - Effects Quality: Low", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",135.677946,134.6082498,135.3220096 "OS X 10.8.0",135.8811344,135.525775,135.5137021 "PostMark 1.51 - Disk Transaction Performance", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",1666,1562,1666,1666,1666 "OS X 10.8.0",1666,1666,1666,1666,1785 "test",235,141,151,134,170,182,186,201,215,204 "10.8.4",227,141,185,190,172,204,185,200,129,111 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",183,195,137,137,263,171,177,186,147,173 "12e52",137,166,208,206,143,101,134,161,195,179 "12e55",155,189,240,91,127,204,176,132,165,128 "bench1mav",111,106,97,107,101,98,98,101,112,104 "Threaded I/O Tester 0.3.3 - Test: Random Write - Size Per Thread: 64MB - Thread Count: 8", Higher Results Are Better "OS X 10.7.4",176.528,173.084,172.897,173.927 "OS X 10.8.0",174.945,172.644,168.108,168.269 "test",44.305,36.433,38.127,37.285,39.394,35.618,37.589,37.9 "10.8.4",36.78,37.182,38.401,36.322 "KINGSTON SVP100S296G",35.963,39.479,39.121,26.731,36.41,30.932,37.251,35.779 "12e52",34.2,36.073,39.625,35.323,41.359,36.379,40.319,37.545 "12e55",34.539,38.516,36.907,41.656,40.593,38.426,37.689,38.365 "OS X 10.7.4 11G63",1.349,1.276,1.215,1.265,1.268,1.054,1.298,1.179