Open-Source vs. Closed-Source Driver GPU Testing On Fedora 19

Intel Core i7-4770K testing with Intel HD Graphics 4600, various AMD Radeon GPUs, and various NVIDIA GeForce GPUs. benchmarking by michael larabel for a future article on Phoronix.com. Also with proprietary NVIDIA and AMD Catalyst drivers added in.

Compare your own system(s) to this result file with the Phoronix Test Suite by running the command: phoronix-test-suite benchmark 1306307-SO-OPENCLOSE17
Jump To Table - Results

View

Do Not Show Noisy Results
Do Not Show Results With Incomplete Data
Do Not Show Results With Little Change/Spread
List Notable Results

Statistics

Show Overall Harmonic Mean(s)
Show Overall Geometric Mean
Show Wins / Losses Counts (Pie Chart)
Normalize Results
Remove Outliers Before Calculating Averages

Graph Settings

Force Line Graphs Where Applicable
Convert To Scalar Where Applicable
Disable Color Branding
Prefer Vertical Bar Graphs
On Line Graphs With Missing Data, Connect The Line Gaps

Multi-Way Comparison

Condense Comparison
Transpose Comparison

Table

Show Detailed System Result Table

Run Management

Highlight
Result
Hide
Result
Result
Identifier
Performance Per
Dollar
Date
Run
  Test
  Duration
Open-Source: Intel HD Graphics 4600
June 28 2013
 
Open-Source: HD 5830
June 27 2013
 
Open-Source: HD 6450
June 27 2013
 
Open-Source: HD 6770
June 28 2013
 
Open-Source: HD 6870
June 27 2013
 
Open-Source: HD 6950
June 27 2013
 
Open-Source: HD 7850
June 27 2013
 
Open-Source: HD 7950
June 27 2013
 
Open-Source: 9500GT
June 28 2013
 
Open-Source: GTX 460
June 28 2013
 
Open-Source: GTX 550 Ti
June 28 2013
 
Open-Source: GTX 680
June 28 2013
 
Closed-Source: GTX 460
June 29 2013
 
Closed-Source: GTX 550 Ti
June 29 2013
 
Closed-Source: 9500GT
June 29 2013
 
Closed-Source: GTX 680
June 30 2013
 
Closed-Source: HD 6770
June 30 2013
 
Closed-Source: HD 6450
June 30 2013
 
Closed-Source: HD 5830
June 30 2013
 
Closed-Source: HD 6950
June 30 2013
 
Closed-Source: HD 6870
June 30 2013
 
Closed-Source: HD 7850
June 30 2013
 
Closed-Source: HD 7950
June 30 2013
 
Invert Hiding All Results Option
 

Only show results where is faster than
Only show results matching title/arguments (delimit multiple options with a comma):
Do not show results matching title/arguments (delimit multiple options with a comma):

Open-Source vs. Closed-Source Driver GPU Testing On Fedora 19, "Xonotic 0.7 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080 - Effects Quality: Low", Higher Results Are Better "Open-Source: Intel HD Graphics 4600",114.4297617,114.6160003,114.4026243 "Open-Source: HD 5830",253.3704238,255.2072171,255.9135565 "Open-Source: HD 6450",58.2924758,58.05081,57.9134306 "Open-Source: HD 6770",253.4674633,249.6176883,249.7781813 "Open-Source: HD 6870",259.3565525,261.2654623,261.7812207 "Open-Source: HD 6950",257.8739654,260.4105371,261.0507151 "Open-Source: HD 7850",48.2772704,48.237616,48.1936203 "Open-Source: HD 7950",85.7425578,85.6199698,85.7139316 "Open-Source: 9500GT",83.4856457,83.4488218,83.2895476 "Open-Source: GTX 460",31.961402,31.9644356,31.9754673 "Open-Source: GTX 550 Ti",79.8100779,80.1908596,79.6465433 "Open-Source: GTX 680",119.9896037,119.3794023,120.2552869 "Closed-Source: GTX 460",313.0609709,319.4769112,311.0883193 "Closed-Source: GTX 550 Ti",310.5898428,309.4398473,303.3624596 "Closed-Source: 9500GT",113.0593293,113.014261,112.9345726 "Closed-Source: GTX 680",309.1182475,315.2155683,318.9022446 "Closed-Source: HD 6770",267.2432122,256.7883189,272.6929591 "Closed-Source: HD 6450",114.43331,114.4275601,114.275818 "Closed-Source: HD 5830",268.1461541,273.4083662,267.6202884 "Closed-Source: HD 6950",263.2540929,263.0951478,263.148559 "Closed-Source: HD 6870",272.8776427,269.9808641,272.2130012 "Closed-Source: HD 7850",253.3061869,248.4361582,254.4918716 "Closed-Source: HD 7950",254.7672312,258.2530529,256.5704241 "Reaction Quake 3 1.0 Beta - Resolution: 1920 x 1080", Higher Results Are Better "Open-Source: Intel HD Graphics 4600",62.6,62.5,62.3 "Open-Source: HD 5830",128.4,134.3,133.7 "Open-Source: HD 6450",24.9,25,25 "Open-Source: HD 6770",123,121.6,125.6 "Open-Source: HD 6870",153.2,149.9,150.5 "Open-Source: HD 6950",135.5,137.2,139.4 "Open-Source: HD 7850",20.6,20.6,20.5 "Open-Source: HD 7950",42.3,42.1,42.6 "Open-Source: 9500GT",35.5,35.5,35.5 "Open-Source: GTX 460",14.8,14.8,14.8 "Open-Source: GTX 550 Ti",38.1,38.1,38.1 "Open-Source: GTX 680",56.4,56.5,56.4 "Closed-Source: GTX 460",305.6,307.4,307.8 "Closed-Source: GTX 550 Ti",283.6,285.5,285.2 "Closed-Source: 9500GT",45,45,45 "Closed-Source: GTX 680",690.8,717.3,713.4 "Closed-Source: HD 6770",360.4,361.5,361.6 "Closed-Source: HD 6450",62.8,62.8,62.8 "Closed-Source: HD 5830",400.3,401.3,401.4 "Closed-Source: HD 6950",597.4,604.3,595.8 "Closed-Source: HD 6870",581.1,573.6,578.9 "Closed-Source: HD 7850",477.8,481.2,482 "Closed-Source: HD 7950",540.4,535.8,544.2 "OpenArena 0.8.8 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080", Higher Results Are Better "Open-Source: Intel HD Graphics 4600",28.8,28.9,28.9 "Open-Source: HD 5830",101.4,101.2,101.9 "Open-Source: HD 6450",14.9,14.9,14.9 "Open-Source: HD 6770",95.6,96,96.4 "Open-Source: HD 6870",169.4,168.7,168.8 "Open-Source: HD 6950",102.2,101.7,102.1 "Open-Source: HD 7850",10.2,10.2,10.2 "Open-Source: HD 7950",15.7,15.7,15.7 "Open-Source: 9500GT",21.1,21.1,21.1 "Open-Source: GTX 460",9.1,9.1,9.1 "Open-Source: GTX 550 Ti",28.1,28.1,28.1 "Open-Source: GTX 680",48.7,49,48.6 "Closed-Source: GTX 460",144.9,144.8,145 "Closed-Source: GTX 550 Ti",120.9,121,121 "Closed-Source: 9500GT",31.7,31.7,31.7 "Closed-Source: GTX 680",388.9,391.7,388.5 "Closed-Source: HD 6770",119.4,120,119.4 "Closed-Source: HD 6450",18.9,18.9,18.9 "Closed-Source: HD 5830",129.8,129.4,129.2 "Closed-Source: HD 6950",215.3,214.8,217 "Closed-Source: HD 6870",198,195.8,197.7 "Closed-Source: HD 7850",215,216.4,215.5 "Closed-Source: HD 7950",238.7,234.4,226.1 "Nexuiz 2.5.2 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080 - HDR: Yes - Sound: Off", Higher Results Are Better "Open-Source: Intel HD Graphics 4600",31.0442804,31.0954538,31.2226834 "Open-Source: HD 5830",96.2259679,96.9788521,96.445101 "Open-Source: HD 6450",15.4977256,15.5007198,15.4967894 "Open-Source: HD 6770",84.5684392,83.9102562,85.0012045 "Open-Source: HD 6870",128.9731473,124.6684752,126.6195004 "Open-Source: HD 6950",96.4677786,97.0342959,101.4912993 "Open-Source: HD 7850",19.967473,19.9687733,19.9737934 "Open-Source: HD 7950",37.8633366,37.8923425,37.7981731 "Open-Source: 9500GT",16.9004511,16.9165304,16.8753937 "Open-Source: GTX 460",8.1046612,8.1065719,8.1120656 "Open-Source: GTX 550 Ti",21.1777316,21.156679,21.1775346 "Open-Source: GTX 680",30.152109,30.3518354,30.5876658 "Closed-Source: GTX 460",164.2168839,168.3481602,167.7894328 "Closed-Source: GTX 550 Ti",148.6239429,155.9790327,154.4161728 "Closed-Source: 9500GT",25.3797073,25.3993897,25.414466 "Closed-Source: GTX 680",228.8886436,262.691515,237.6640016,255.4198529,255.3673701,261.2506162 "Closed-Source: HD 6770",124.9136945,121.658699,122.4971963 "Closed-Source: HD 6450",26.4961494,26.4367058,26.4797705 "Closed-Source: HD 5830",142.8735876,141.4263433,142.6401695 "Closed-Source: HD 6950",159.9784498,154.0569664,156.4832907 "Closed-Source: HD 6870",151.5545178,153.3793875,153.8061517 "Closed-Source: HD 7850",153.7706351,146.4078212,145.1753636 "Closed-Source: HD 7950",149.8820746,146.5449851,148.0108345 "OpenArena 0.8.5 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080", Higher Results Are Better "Open-Source: Intel HD Graphics 4600",137.9,137.7,137.8 "Open-Source: HD 5830",308.9,318.7,305.2 "Open-Source: HD 6450",54.1,54.2,53.9 "Open-Source: HD 6770",298.7,286.4,293.7 "Open-Source: HD 6870",401.3,404.9,404.7 "Open-Source: HD 6950",361.1,363.4,357.1 "Open-Source: HD 7850",48.2,48.1,48 "Open-Source: HD 7950",82.5,80.9,81.4 "Open-Source: 9500GT",81.9,81.7,82 "Open-Source: GTX 460",31,31,31 "Open-Source: GTX 550 Ti",76.2,76.2,76.2 "Open-Source: GTX 680",122.6,122.8,123 "Closed-Source: GTX 460",571.2,577.9,573.3 "Closed-Source: GTX 550 Ti",506.7,508.7,510.3 "Closed-Source: 9500GT",114.5,114.4,114.7 "Closed-Source: GTX 680",698.5,729.4,720.1 "Closed-Source: HD 6770",433.1,415.6,431.9 "Closed-Source: HD 6450",100,100.7,102.3 "Closed-Source: HD 5830",426.6,444.4,441.8 "Closed-Source: HD 6950",486.7,472.1,493.8 "Closed-Source: HD 6870",481.9,470.4,478.5 "Closed-Source: HD 7850",423.6,429,428.7 "Closed-Source: HD 7950",437,446.4,453.7 "Xonotic 0.7 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080 - Effects Quality: Ultra", Higher Results Are Better "Open-Source: Intel HD Graphics 4600",42.5542659,42.564938,42.5675349 "Open-Source: HD 5830",106.8944086,107.9444939,107.2126926 "Open-Source: HD 6450",19.9287913,19.924869,19.9247776 "Open-Source: HD 6770",82.2630095,83.0692289,82.1958983 "Open-Source: HD 6870",128.722072,127.185677,128.1607805 "Open-Source: HD 6950",138.1225617,138.8290566,138.7586548 "Open-Source: HD 7850",29.939992,30.1515115,30.0397595 "Open-Source: HD 7950",51.7783124,51.9585322,51.7696308 "Open-Source: 9500GT",12.9355205,12.9342573,12.9322043 "Open-Source: GTX 460",11.625676,11.625278,11.6243301 "Open-Source: GTX 550 Ti",32.265671,32.3051028,32.3192125 "Open-Source: GTX 680",56.3237115,56.2071385,56.2003077 "Closed-Source: GTX 460",162.6288822,162.0085684,163.1183382 "Closed-Source: GTX 550 Ti",146.6429858,148.4013691,148.3730783 "Closed-Source: 9500GT",19.5096309,19.5045325,19.5032756 "Closed-Source: GTX 680",222.0966509,219.3622978,215.5203124 "Closed-Source: HD 6770",136.2830447,136.5147673,136.1012819 "Closed-Source: HD 6450",28.6394252,28.6294083,28.624481 "Closed-Source: HD 5830",150.2382626,149.7756391,148.7326252 "Closed-Source: HD 6950",160.5713516,161.0915008,161.4733149 "Closed-Source: HD 6870",159.0188585,158.940659,158.9010205 "Closed-Source: HD 7850",151.5977691,152.3894077,152.3201164 "Closed-Source: HD 7950",153.7216957,156.3961843,156.6285053 "World of Padman 1.2 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080", Higher Results Are Better "Open-Source: Intel HD Graphics 4600",136.8,137.3,137.2 "Open-Source: HD 5830",342.4,334.5,341.6 "Open-Source: HD 6450",67.8,67.9,68 "Open-Source: HD 6770",329.1,336.4,336.6 "Open-Source: HD 6870",339.9,353.8,361.7 "Open-Source: HD 6950",358.3,361.6,355 "Open-Source: HD 7850",52.1,52,52.1 "Open-Source: HD 7950",93.5,93.3,93.4 "Open-Source: 9500GT",88.9,89.1,88.9 "Open-Source: GTX 460",36,36,36 "Open-Source: GTX 550 Ti",84,84.5,84.2 "Open-Source: GTX 680",127.7,127.5,127.8 "Closed-Source: GTX 460",583.3,572.6,585.9 "Closed-Source: GTX 550 Ti",570.4,555.3,570.3 "Closed-Source: 9500GT",118.9,118.8,118.7 "Closed-Source: GTX 680",623.3,626.3,630.1 "Closed-Source: HD 6770",423,435.8,415.5 "Closed-Source: HD 6450",139.9,139.9,139.9 "Closed-Source: HD 5830",426.7,426,425.3 "Closed-Source: HD 6950",422.5,416.8,418.6 "Closed-Source: HD 6870",407.1,408.6,401.5 "Closed-Source: HD 7850",373.8,355.8,354.8 "Closed-Source: HD 7950",359.3,360.6,333.1,360.1,366.7,351.8 "Xonotic 0.7 - Resolution: 1920 x 1080 - Effects Quality: High", Higher Results Are Better "Open-Source: Intel HD Graphics 4600",57.9373672,57.9307034,57.9259071 "Open-Source: HD 5830",151.2084705,153.0098442,153.0377766 "Open-Source: HD 6450",27.3696367,27.3766246,27.3741602 "Open-Source: HD 6770",140.499862,140.0264353,140.6824089 "Open-Source: HD 6870",173.2200863,173.3090596,172.5612931 "Open-Source: HD 6950",168.1518049,168.1929118,167.9047444 "Open-Source: HD 7850",24.9629948,24.9781229,24.9816881 "Open-Source: HD 7950",44.1112634,44.1186337,44.2061083 "Open-Source: 9500GT",30.6822042,30.6695279,30.6787485 "Open-Source: GTX 460",15.0218883,15.0196489,15.0203004 "Open-Source: GTX 550 Ti",38.3640902,38.359847,38.3562494 "Open-Source: GTX 680",62.8233767,62.6375647,62.7404594 "Closed-Source: GTX 460",214.7802528,206.6307194,214.914849 "Closed-Source: GTX 550 Ti",201.3074911,203.2259948,203.2251966 "Closed-Source: 9500GT",43.1303062,43.1365795,43.1067531 "Closed-Source: GTX 680",243.4115717,249.2998074,241.2781505 "Closed-Source: HD 6770",175.8818495,177.086774,175.9866825 "Closed-Source: HD 6450",40.479544,40.4846228,40.4618172 "Closed-Source: HD 5830",182.4418196,181.813863,180.4816718 "Closed-Source: HD 6950",188.9948803,187.9026016,185.8636032 "Closed-Source: HD 6870",187.530854,187.40622,187.7038076 "Closed-Source: HD 7850",177.3648917,178.5676789,176.9134869 "Closed-Source: HD 7950",182.4844645,182.2345837,181.2535664 "Xonotic 0.7 - Resolution: 1280 x 1024 - Effects Quality: Ultimate", Higher Results Are Better "Closed-Source: HD 7950",116.5922432,111.5039401,115.136725